
Let Sudan’s President Come to New York. Then Arrest Him.
Brilliant NY Times article by my friend and former ICC chief prosecutor Luis Moreno Ocampo.
“THE fugitive president of Sudan, Omar Hassan al-Bashir, plans to attend a United Nations gathering later this month in New York City on the future of global development. To travel here, he needs a visa. His application for a visa gives President Obama an opportunity to take a landmark stance in the slow evolution of international efforts to prevent genocide.
A century ago, when more than one million Armenians were exterminated, the word “genocide” did not exist. Killing millions of people was a domestic affair in which no foreign country could intervene.
Only after the Holocaust did this state of affairs change. In 1948, the United Nations General Assembly adopted a genocide convention, which rejected the idea that “rulers” are immune from accountability for killing their people, and envisioned an “international penal tribunal” to try them. It took until 1988 for the United States to ratify the convention.
Ten years after that, in 1998, 120 countries voted to establish the permanent International Criminal Court to prosecute war crimes, crimes against humanity and genocide. The United States has not signed on. Nonetheless, in 2005, President George W. Bush accepted a United Nations Security Council resolution that referred the Darfur case to the I.C.C.
In 2008, as the I.C.C. chief prosecutor, I requested arrest warrants against Mr. Bashir for genocide. Mr. Bush pushed for the deployment of peacekeepers to Darfur and for humanitarian assistance. I.C.C. judges issued arrest warrants in 2009 against Mr. Bashir for crimes against humanity and war crimes and in 2010 for genocide. The challenge now is to arrest him.
Sadly, Mr. Bashir’s ability to commit atrocities in full sight of the international community has kept ahead of humanity’s ability to protect genocide victims. Rape and hunger are his new silent weapons, replacing open attacks on villages. To avoid the international spotlight, the Sudanese government expels aid workers and denies access to refugee camps. Mr. Bashir has tried to shift attention from his criminal actions by making the argument that the I.C.C. is biased against Africans.
Who will arrest Mr. Bashir? While he is in power, Sudanese forces certainly will not arrest him, and the Security Council did not authorize the use of force to execute the arrest warrant. The only remaining option is to arrest him when he is visiting foreign countries.
Mr. Bashir tried to visit South Africa in 2009 and 2010, but was informed that he would be arrested if he did. Earlier this year, the South African government relented, offering him immunity so he could attend an African Union meeting in Johannesburg. However, a South African judge ordered his arrest; Mr. Bashir managed to get away as the court proceedings were underway.
In 2013, Sudan’s government requested a United States visa in his name, to attend the annual General Assembly meetings in New York. The American ambassador to the United Nations, Samantha Power, said “it would be more appropriate” for Mr. Bashir to travel to The Hague, where the I.C.C. is based, than to New York.
Sudan ultimately called off the trip. And the Obama administration hasn’t given any indication as to what it will do this time. Under the convention that designated New York as the headquarters of the United Nations, the United States is supposed to grant visas to leaders traveling to United Nations events, with a very limited exception for national security.
In effect, Mr. Bashir is betting that support from some African leaders, the intelligence his government can provide about terrorist organizations in East Africa, and America’s need to manage Sudan’s ongoing conflict with South Sudan, will make the United States look away.
Contrary to conventional wisdom, the United States doesn’t have to let Mr. Bashir in. If it does, it should arrest him when he arrives. Under the Nuremberg Charter, the genocide convention and the I.C.C. statute, there is no immunity for heads of state who face charges before international tribunals.
Furthermore, a federal law, the American Service Members Protection Act, authorizes federal support of international efforts “to bring to justice” foreigners accused of atrocities. Under that law, a Rwandan warlord, Bosco Ntaganda, was surrendered to the I.C.C. in 2013.
Mr. Obama has a political choice. The United States should grant Mr. Bashir his visa, and then, upon his arrival, arrest and surrender him to the I.C.C., where he could present any legal arguments he wishes about innocence, immunity or alleged prosecutorial bias. This would represent an important stand. The United States should do everything it can to isolate Mr. Bashir and express its solidarity with the people of Darfur and its commitment to prevent and punish genocide.”
Luis Moreno-Ocampo, the chief prosecutor of the International Criminal Court from 2003 to 2012, is a lawyer at Getnick & Getnick and an associate at the Carr Center for Human Rights Policy at the Kennedy School of Government at Harvard.
Articles

EDUCATING FOR TOLERANCE
By Media & Press
12-04-2018
Tolerance… Except in select circles, it’s a word…

HE SIGNIFICANCE OF THE IRAN ACCORD WITHIN THE CONTEXT OF RISING NATIONALISM
By Media & Press
11-16-2018
For a time, early on in US President Donald Trump’s administration…

THE DEATH OF JAMAL KHASHOGGI AND ITS MESSAGE ABOUT THE GEOPOLITICAL CLIMATE WE LIVE IN
By Media & Press
10-29-2018
By now, there can be little doubt in any realistic person’s mind…

A FRIGHTENING CLIMATE REPORT FROM THE UN…BUT NOTHING ENVIRONMENTALISTS HAVEN’T BEEN TELLING US FOR YEARS NOW
By Media & Press
10-17-2018
After reading through the latest UN report…

NEW UNITED NATIONS REPORT DETAILS THE ROHINGYA GENOCIDE.
By Roberto Vivo
10-02-2018
In its most damning report yet…

Education and alternatives for the future: Part two
By Media & Press
09-19-2018
The exponential increase…

Challenges of Today, Implications for the Future: Part Two
By Media & Press
08-22-2018
In War – A Crime Against Humanity …

Education and alternatives for the future: Part one
By Media & Press
08-28-2018
In 1984, James Cameron …

Challenges of Today, Implications for the Future: Part One
By Roberto Vivo
07-13-2018
The crumbling of democracy…

Forced child marriages – and the case of Noura Hussein
By Roberto Vivo
06-12-2018
The case of Noura Hussein…

US Withdrawal from the Iran Nuclear Accord and its dangerous consequences
By Roberto Vivo
06-03-2018
The US president’s unilateral decision…

A heart-wrenching story behind Advanced Technology
By Roberto Vivo
05-26-2018
We are ever more dependent on…


SYRIA: Power Games and Utter Indifference to a veritable HELL ON EARTH
By Roberto Vivo
04-06-2018
The announcement this past week

Stephen Hawking: The Passing of an Immortal Man of Science and Peace
By Roberto Vivo
03-23-2018
It would be fair to say that…

Me Too and Never Again: A Revolution in the making?
By Roberto Vivo
03-05-2018
There is a revolution afoot and …

Life 3.0 — Real life, Sci-fi, or a little of both?
By Roberto Vivo
02-22-2018
I recently read, with enthusiasm and fascination…

Women getting organized…NOW
By Roberto Vivo
02-05-2018
It is called NOW, and that’s no coincidence…

The Trial and Conviction of Ratko Mladic
By Roberto Vivo
12-09-2017
Last month witnessed the final…

Nobel Peace Prize and a Nuclear Wake-up Call
By Roberto Vivo
12-23-2017
Setsuko Nakamura Thurlow was born…

Democracy’s Fate in 2017 and how it bodes for the future.
By Roberto Vivo
01-11-2018
Those of us who grew up in…

A Commemoration without Fanfare
By Roberto Vivo
11-25-2017
This month marked the centennial …

Venezuela—From Rising Star to Shooting Star
By Roberto Vivo
10-01-2017
ince its independence in the early 1800s…

The Rohingya Genocide and Myanmar’s pseudo-democracy
By Roberto Vivo
09-24-2017
In what has swiftly become the world’s…

Women’s Rights: Equality starts with The Vote
By Roberto Vivo
08-30-2017
This month marks the 97th anniversary…

Other viewpoints on Unconditional Income
By Roberto Vivo
08-19-2017
The general idea behind the theory of Universal Basic Income…

Milton Friedman: A Conservative voice for free money for all
By Roberto Vivo
07-31-2017
Milton Friedman, who died in 2006 …

More on Macron and meeting in the middle
By Roberto Vivo
07-11-2017
Back in May, I analyzed the French presidential…

Universal Basic Income – Introduction to a controversy whose day is coming.
By Roberto Vivo
06-23-2017
For some time now, the warning signs…

UN WOMEN – Marking the way to Gender Equality
By Roberto Vivo
06-02-2017
On July 2 of the current year…

Mexico’s Drug War—the 2nd deadliest conflict on earth
By Roberto Vivo
05-27-2017
The murder on May 15th of …

The French Election and what it means to Democracy
By Roberto Vivo
05-14-2017
Vive la démocratie française!..

Hunger: The basic problem NO ONE is willing to fix
By Roberto Vivo
05-02-2017
Armed with the dramatic latest report from…

The Forgotten Role of the European Union
By Roberto Vivo
04-09-2017
In 2012, the Nobel Prize Committee awarded the European Union…

Turkish Democracy at the Crossroads
By Roberto Vivo
03-31-2017
On April 16th, Turkish voters will go to the polls…

The elusive goal of Gender Equality
By Roberto Vivo
03-22-2017
The issue of gender equality has achieved, on a worldwide scale…

Steve Bannon: an American Rasputin
By Roberto Vivo
03-06-2017
Last year, when few people had ever heard of Steve Bannon …

Populist Nationalism forces the IMF to change its Tune
By Roberto Vivo
02-17-2017
The sudden rise of the latest expressions of populist nationalism…

The ICC and the Cost of Imbalanced Justice
By Roberto Vivo
01-31-2017
This past week, the foreign ministers of African Union …

The International Criminal Court in a nutshell
By Roberto Vivo
01-18-2017
Imagine for a moment that you have a beef with your neighbors…

NETANYAHU Takes on The World
By Roberto Vivo
01-04-2017
If you were to ask Israel’s pugnacious Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu…

Putin flexes his muscles and goes for the Gold… Black Gold
By Roberto Vivo
12-26-2016
By now, it is no secret that Russian strongman Vladimir Putin is…

The fall of Aleppo
By Roberto Vivo
12-20-2016
For months now, Aleppo has been in the grip of hell on earth…

Worst Case Scenario
By Roberto Vivo
11-30-2016
I’ve been mulling over this month’s historic US presidential election…

An American Tragedy (From The New Yorker)
By Roberto Vivo
11-18-2016
The election of Donald Trump to the Presidency…

The Rise of Populist Nationalism: Part IV — The Inequality Factor
By Roberto Vivo
10-24-2016
Although an undercurrent of populist nationalism has been surging…

The Rise of Populist Nationalism: PART III — Root Causes
By Roberto Vivo
09-23-2016
In a recently released documentary video written and directed by…

The rise of Populist Nationalism: Part II — Apparent Causes
By Roberto Vivo
08-26-2016
Despite the general proliferation of far-right nationalist…

The rise of Nationalist Populism: Authoritarianism 101
By Roberto Vivo
08-11-2016
Ever since World War II, people in the Western world have been asking…

The Erdogan Connection
By Roberto Vivo
07-28-2016
Turkey’s close call with a military coup…

No More Walls: Part Two — Trying to fence out Responsibilities from the Past
By Roberto Vivo
07-06-2016
There can be little doubt that the result of last week’s referendum in Britain…

No more walls: part one — The Iconic Wall-raiser
By Roberto Vivo
06-14-2016
Walls. The very symbol of curtailment, of intransigence…

Falling short: Barack Obama’s visit to Japan’s Ground Zero
By Roberto Vivo
05-31-2016
In a tweet I posted earlier this year when Washington was still on…

Who’s afraid of donald trump? Short answer: anyone sane
By Roberto Vivo
05-06-2016
“The Donald” Trump is now, to the chagrin of much of that party, the virtual Republican (GOP) candidate for president …

Three minutes to midnight
By Roberto Vivo
04-21-2016
Those of us who grew up in the 1950s and 1960s remember…

Rape as a weapon of war
By Roberto Vivo
04-11-2016
An article by Kevin Sieff earlier this month in The Washington Post…

When a world leader comes to call
By Roberto Vivo
03-28-2016
Yesterday I asked myself a rhetorical question…

Making the weather in a Proxy War
By Roberto Vivo
03-11-2016
Fragile tightrope though it might be, the so-called “cessation of hostilities”…

The truce in Syria is no such thing
By Roberto Vivo
02-18-2016
Any inkling of some semblance of peace in Syria following…

UK-US arms sales help bolster Saudi attacks on Yemen civilians
By Roberto Vivo
02-10-2016
Many attacks involved multiple airstrikes on multiple civilian objects…

Syria’s quest for Democracy and the cost of Superpower Hypocrisy
By Roberto Vivo
“This is where the revolution happens first,” say Leila Al-Shami and Robin Yassin-Kassab…

Educating for Peace
By Roberto Vivo
01-18-2016
It was my honor this past week to accept an invitation to visit Harvard University.

The fruits of peace and justice
By Roberto Vivo
01-11-2016
Pope Francis has made world peace a priority message of the Roman Catholic Church

Two major take-aways from 2015
By Roberto Vivo
01-04-2016
In reviewing the year that ended last night, there are two things that stand out …

Trump: the new face of the legendary Ugly American
By Roberto Vivo
12-18-2015
It’s fairly easy to underestimate the gratingly flamboyant US presidential candidate Donald Trump.

New times for old fears
By Roberto Vivo
10-30-2015
I think I speak for many when I say that…

SYRIA – Universal Battlefield
By Roberto Vivo
10-20-2015
Syria is the new battlefield for the world’s proxy…

What Russian intervention brings to the War in Syria
By Roberto Vivo
10-14-2015
As of this first week of October, Syria (and the world) became a lot scarier place…

World Beyond War and the Quest for Peace
By Roberto Vivo
09-25-2015
Directed by author and international peace activist David Swanson…

The International Day of Peace
By Roberto Vivo
09-23-2015
21st September. There’s no way to peace. Peace is the way.

Why the Iran Nuclear Talks Matter
By Roberto Vivo
07-19-2015
A deadline came and went without incident last Tuesday, in talks being held in Vienna between Iran and the so-called…

Some Thoughts on the Iran Nuclear Deal
By Roberto Vivo
07-28-2015
Few except the most adamant of “Iranophobes” on the outer reactionary fringe in the United States…
Take a look at the trailer on this book that will change your ideas about war forever.
By Roberto Vivo
07-31-2015

The Fundamentalist Surge
By Roberto Vivo
07-09-2015
The lightning surge of the Sunni militant ISIL (Islamic State in Iraq and the Levant, a.k.a. ISIS) that took shape earlier this month appears to

UKRAINE: A Cold War Retrospective
By Roberto Vivo
This past week’s decision by the Crimean parliament to secede from Ukraine and join the Russian Federation took the international political crisis

The Children of War
By Roberto Vivo
In my recent book, El crimen de la guerra (soon to be published in English as War Is a Crime against Humanity), I propose that war is no longer

Thinking Big: Tearing Down Walls and Building Peace
By Roberto Vivo
On a journey this past week to East Asia, one of my goals as a traveler was to visit that man-made wonder of the world known as the Great Wall of China

With Pope Francis at The Vatican
By Roberto Vivo
I was present yesterday at the Vatican when His Holiness, Pope Francis, closed the Fourth Annual Congress of Scholas Occurrentes

Scholas Occurrentes in The Vatican: Educating for Peace
By Roberto Vivo
This week, I’ve had the enormous pleasure of being invited to take part in the Fourth Scholas Occurrentes World Congress at the Vatican, a project

How Peace Fared in 2014
By Roberto Vivo
The past year has been a difficult one for world peace. This has been true not only because of the severity and escalation of civil and regional wars

Salute to a Man of Law and Peace
By Roberto Vivo
Ben Ferencz is the kind of guy you like right off—friendly, smiling, open, and incredibly humble considering his stunning achievements.

The Usual Suspects
By Roberto Vivo
Last Monday marked the one-hundredth anniversary of the start of World War I, one of the two bloodiest and most horrendous conflicts

The American Pussy Riot
By Roberto Vivo
The incident in which Cecily has been tried and convicted took place on March 17, 2012 (Saint Patrick’s Day). It occurred during the eviction of protesters

Cecily and Mahienour—When the personal and political overlap
By Roberto Vivo
An incident in high-profile civil disobedience in Egypt, where court actions and death…

The Cost of Underestimating Radical Islam
By Roberto Vivo
The emergence of a seemingly endless parade of radical Islamist groups…

The ISIL Challenge
By Roberto Vivo
Since the beginning of 2014—the year in which the world was…

Measuring Peace and Justice
By Roberto Vivo
Some people divide the world into optimists and pessimists, into positive and negative thinkers, into “glass half-full and glass half-empty” types